Difference between revisions of "Status Meetings:2011-02-09:Agenda"

From Camino Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(all but crashes?)
 
Line 5: Line 5:
 
* Camino 2.1a1
 
* Camino 2.1a1
 
** Released three weeks ago Thursday
 
** Released three weeks ago Thursday
** [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byversion/Camino/2.1a1/14 Breakpad] topcrash report for the last 2 weeks - 33 (100%) (+20)<!--  --> (Also: [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byurl/Camino/2.1a1 topcrashers by URL])
+
** [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byversion/Camino/2.1a1/14 Breakpad] topcrash report for the last 2 weeks - 42 (100%) (+9)<!--  --> (Also: [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byurl/Camino/2.1a1 topcrashers by URL])
 
*** Low crash volume, low user volume (a bit lower than what 2.0a1 had before 2.0b1 released)
 
*** Low crash volume, low user volume (a bit lower than what 2.0a1 had before 2.0b1 released)
*** Flash 10.1 and 1Password tied for top crash (all the libobjc.A.dylib@0x5edb/0x5ed7 and the objc_msgSend | NSToolbar and objc_msgSend | -[NSView setFrameSize:] crashes are 1P)
+
**# Flash 10.1/10.2 (31%)
 +
**# 1Password (12%)
 +
**# nsNPAPIPluginInstance::InitializePlugin() on http://www.sistersshoppingonashoestring.com/ (7%)
 +
**# VP3VideoDecoder_DecodeFrameCompleteCallback (5%)
  
 
* Camino 2.0.6
 
* Camino 2.0.6
 
** Released 12 weeks ago Tuesday
 
** Released 12 weeks ago Tuesday
 
** flash-check results have been positive
 
** flash-check results have been positive
** [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byversion/Camino/2.0.6/14 Breakpad] topcrash report for the last 2 weeks - 1967 (78.63%) (-~1150)  (Also: [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byurl/Camino/2.0.6 topcrashers by URL])
+
** [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byversion/Camino/2.0.6/14 Breakpad] topcrash report for the last 2 weeks - 1366 (78.77%) (-~600)  (Also: [http://crash-stats.mozilla.com/topcrasher/byurl/Camino/2.0.6 topcrashers by URL])
*** Massive drop in crashes (75% in two weeks since Socorro upgrade) - unsure why; filed {{bug|630798}}
+
*** Massive drop in crashes since Socorro upgrade ({{bug|630798}}) was due to improper throttling; fixed now, numbers should be near normal next week
*** Top sites: facebook, google, gmail, caminobrowser.org, omegle, aljazeera  
+
*** Top sites: facebook, caminobrowser.org, google, aljazeera, youtube 
*** #1 <!--97--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|FlashPlayer-10.6}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|FlashPlayer-10.4-10.5}} (12%)
+
*** #1 <!--208--> is F*_ / {{BPsig|2.0.6|FlashPlayer-10.6}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|FlashPlayer-10.4-10.5}} (15%)
*** #2 <!--41--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bNSApplication%20sendEvent:%5d}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|libobjc.A.dylib@0x5ed7}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|libobjc.A.dylib@0x5edb}} (unknown bug) (5%)
+
*** #2 <!--73--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bNSApplication%20sendEvent:%5d}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|libobjc.A.dylib@0x5ed7}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|libobjc.A.dylib@0x5edb}} (unknown bug) (5%)
*** #3 <!--22--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|_eFOGetName}} ({{bug|533395}} - probably not fixable) (3%)
+
*** #3 <!--32--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|VP3VideoDecoder_DecodeFrameCompleteCallback}} ({{bug|630199}}; Flash crash on aljazeera, turned out to be Flash bug fixed in 10.2) (2%)
*** #4 <!--16--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|VP3VideoDecoder_DecodeFrameCompleteCallback}} ({{bug|630199}}; Flash crash on aljazeera, josh+Adobe think it's an OS bug) (2%)
+
*** #4 <!--30--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|_eFOGetName}} ({{bug|533395}} - probably not fixable) (2%)
*** #5 <!--15--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20IdleTimerVector}} (Divx+WebKit+autorelease pools; see {{bug|509130}} and its regressions for the gory story) (2%)
+
*** #5 <!--27--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bNSWindow%20sendEvent:%5d}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|AppKit@0x6412c}} (unknown bug) (2%)
*** #6 <!--14--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bNSWindow%20sendEvent:%5d}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|AppKit@0x6412c}} (unknown bug) (2%)
+
*** #7 <!--23--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20Foundation@0x50ebf}} (10.4.11 -[NSException raise]; assorted unknown exceptions) (2%)
*** #7 <!--12--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|pthread_mutex_lock}} (related to Veetle and Move-Media-Player; Comcast Xfinity appears to use something that triggers this) (1%)
+
*** #6 <!--22--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|Flash%20Player}} (2%)
*** #8 <!--10--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|Flash%20Player}} (1%)
+
*** #8 <!--21--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20_nsnote_callback}} (mostly related to closing windows with a mouse) (2%)
*** #9 <!--10--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|JS_CallTracer}} (generic Gecko JS sig) (1%)
+
*** #9 <!--15--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20IdleTimerVector}} (Divx+WebKit+autorelease pools; see {{bug|509130}} and its regressions for the gory story) (1%)
*** #9 <!--10--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20Foundation@0x50ebf}} (10.4.11 -[NSException raise]; assorted unknown exceptions) (1%)
+
*** #9 <!--15--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|CFBasicHashReplaceValue}} ?? (1%)
 +
*** #9 <!--15--> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|gmtsub}} (libSystem.B; related to libcrypto+Flash) (1%)
 
<!--
 
<!--
*** #7 <!- -33- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|CFBasicHashReplaceValue}} ?? (1%)
+
 
*** #9 <!- -32- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20_nsnote_callback}} (mostly related to closing windows with a mouse) (1%)
+
*** #8 <!- -12- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|pthread_mutex_lock}} (related to Veetle and Move-Media-Player; Comcast Xfinity appears to use something that triggers this) (1%)
 +
*** #9 <!- -10- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|JS_CallTracer}} (generic Gecko JS sig) (1%)
  
 
*** #8 <!- -30- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|_objc_error}} (unknown bug) (1%)
 
*** #8 <!- -30- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|_objc_error}} (unknown bug) (1%)
Line 33: Line 38:
 
*** #10 <!- -26- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|Foundation@0x41548}} (10.4.11 _NSRaiseError; assorted unknown exceptions) (1%)
 
*** #10 <!- -26- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|Foundation@0x41548}} (10.4.11 _NSRaiseError; assorted unknown exceptions) (1%)
 
*** #10 <!- -23- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSendSuper%20%7c%20AppKit@0x46c44}} (10.4.11 PPC via [http://bonsai.mozilla.org/cvsblame.cgi?file=mozilla/widget/src/cocoa/nsChildView.mm&rev=1.371.10.1&mark=1548#1548 nsChildView::Update], mostly on eBay and Yahoo!Mail) (1%)
 
*** #10 <!- -23- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSendSuper%20%7c%20AppKit@0x46c44}} (10.4.11 PPC via [http://bonsai.mozilla.org/cvsblame.cgi?file=mozilla/widget/src/cocoa/nsChildView.mm&rev=1.371.10.1&mark=1548#1548 nsChildView::Update], mostly on eBay and Yahoo!Mail) (1%)
*** #7 <!- -23- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|gmtsub}} (libSystem.B; related to libcrypto+Flash) (1%)
 
  
 
*** #2 <!- -195- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bKeychainBrowserListener%20onLoadingCompleted:%5d}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bKeychainBrowserListener%fillDOMWindow:%5d}} (7%) - {{bug|512730}}
 
*** #2 <!- -195- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bKeychainBrowserListener%20onLoadingCompleted:%5d}} / {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bKeychainBrowserListener%fillDOMWindow:%5d}} (7%) - {{bug|512730}}
Line 40: Line 44:
  
 
*** #5 <!- -45- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|CFQSortArray}} (related to appshell/runloop) (1%)
 
*** #5 <!- -45- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|CFQSortArray}} (related to appshell/runloop) (1%)
-->
 
<!--
 
  
 
*** #6 <!- -63- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|HashString(nsAString_internal%20const%26)}} ({{bug|458645}}) (2%)
 
*** #6 <!- -63- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|HashString(nsAString_internal%20const%26)}} ({{bug|458645}}) (2%)
<!- -
 
  
 
*** #7 <!- -22- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|StartDraw}} (QuickTime) (1%)
 
*** #7 <!- -22- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|StartDraw}} (QuickTime) (1%)
Line 62: Line 63:
 
*** #8 <!- -10- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20nsNativeThemeCocoa::DrawPushButton}} - {{bug|530343}} - déjà vu crash: {{bug|458961}} (Core) aka {{bug|461715}} (Tabsposé) aka offscreen surfaces and exceptions - why didn't that fix this? (1%)
 
*** #8 <!- -10- -> is {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20nsNativeThemeCocoa::DrawPushButton}} - {{bug|530343}} - déjà vu crash: {{bug|458961}} (Core) aka {{bug|461715}} (Tabsposé) aka offscreen surfaces and exceptions - why didn't that fix this? (1%)
  
 +
** 10.4.11 PPC crashes in {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSendSuper%20%7c%20%252B%5bCHSelectPopupDisplayer%20showNativePopupMenuAsynchronouslyForSelect:%5d}} -->
 +
** 3 new {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bBrowserWindowController%20tabView:didSelectTabViewItem:%5d}} LastPass-related crashes again this week; same three different ModuleIDs as last time: C2941749C8985F56EEC6003C52EACC260, E403C1179810E5A5AD46D7988D47ABB00 (i386 1.70.0), FB35E92152AB820318A1FAE855E9EC2F0
  
** New LastPass-related crash in NSString: {{bp|b4b54f19-9335-4d12-948f-a69892101124}}
+
* People on 10.6, please run http://www.ardisson.org/smokey/moz/moduleid.zip and let me know what it reports; looking for
** {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bBrowserWindowController%20tabView:didSelectTabViewItem:%5d}} crashes were apparently LastPass-related<!- -; {{bp|f1494cd1-cae6-406e-8a00-d50c42101116}} has an email- ->
+
**3308DD745D0361892AFD63BF06848E910
** 10.4.11 PPC crashes in {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSendSuper%20%7c%20%252B%5bCHSelectPopupDisplayer%20showNativePopupMenuAsynchronouslyForSelect:%5d}}
+
**C8925910B927968B4B71D83A4CEF86460
 
+
**F237B77D75A37240931D4735B91D365F0
** 8 new {{BPsig|2.0.6|objc_msgSend%20%7c%20-%5bBrowserWindowController%20tabView:didSelectTabViewItem:%5d}} LastPass-related crashes again this week; three different ModuleIDs: C2941749C8985F56EEC6003C52EACC260 (more often), E403C1179810E5A5AD46D7988D47ABB00 (i386 1.70.0), FB35E92152AB820318A1FAE855E9EC2F0
+
**22CD62D49E7DC31AF585FCEF1FE4C39A0
** 1Password still crashing people during toolbar customization (even the latest scripting addition hack) -->
 
  
 
===Other Releases===
 
===Other Releases===

Revision as of 23:44, 8 February 2011

Wed 9 Feb 1pm PST (21:00 GMT/UTC) in #camino-mtg

General Plans

Current Release

  • Camino 2.1a1
    • Released three weeks ago Thursday
    • Breakpad topcrash report for the last 2 weeks - 42 (100%) (+9) (Also: topcrashers by URL)
      • Low crash volume, low user volume (a bit lower than what 2.0a1 had before 2.0b1 released)
      1. Flash 10.1/10.2 (31%)
      2. 1Password (12%)
      3. nsNPAPIPluginInstance::InitializePlugin() on http://www.sistersshoppingonashoestring.com/ (7%)
      4. VP3VideoDecoder_DecodeFrameCompleteCallback (5%)
  • People on 10.6, please run http://www.ardisson.org/smokey/moz/moduleid.zip and let me know what it reports; looking for
    • 3308DD745D0361892AFD63BF06848E910
    • C8925910B927968B4B71D83A4CEF86460
    • F237B77D75A37240931D4735B91D365F0
    • 22CD62D49E7DC31AF585FCEF1FE4C39A0

Other Releases

  • Camino 2.0.7
    • KeychainBrowserListener - no flare-ups lately
    • Flashblock upgrade (see Specific bugs that need action below)
    • Security fixes
    • "new JEP regression" fix (Bug 610525)
    • Need to see if Bug 567552 affects 2.0.x, and if we can fix it by calling the function before initing Gecko (no response from jdaggett yet in the bug)
    • Bug 532186 - can't paste URLs into Flash exceptions list - hendy's been offline
    • Have new "Profile Startup" bug (Bug 556428) covering about year+ of Ts regressions
  • Camino 2.1
    • Most of the items from the list have been twiddled to reflect state, plus editorial comments
    • autocomplete - mostly UI work left; Stuart starting on integrated ranking
    • dtd localization - should be ready now; waiting on sr
    • Gecko 1.9.2 update - (tracking for bugs+issues; mostly filed, but need to get focus-related bugs filed)
      • Gecko focus/blackholes - new meta filed (Bug 600483); the worst ones have been fixed
      • Regressions: about:config probably biggest remaining
    • No progress on patch-free 10.6 building (mozsqlite:Bug 513747+friends) in a long time
    • Beta 1 - ????
      • Feature freeze, l10n freeze
  • Gecko 2.0 fka 1.9.3 - on ice

Other Items

  • Tinderboxen
  • AppZapper
    • Sam mailed them again two weeks ago
  • Weekly Bugs and Queues update
    • r queue still OK; pink side of sr queue has stalled for a couple weeks now

Specific bugs that need action

  • Upgrade to Flashblock 1.5.14 (Bug 604477) is going to require some small code changes
  • Need hints from smorgan/murph on Bug 585535 - getting diagnostic URL into SafeBrowsingAboutModule
  • Adding a "show cert" button to the technical details of about:certerror needs lots of plumbing
  • Need test code for 10.5 AppKit menu changes (Cmd-=, alternates/NSEvents)
  • CBSamplePane - cancelled reviews; needs updating for 2.0/10.4 baseline

Other bugs (if there's time)

  • 10.5 Visual UX
  • UNCOs
    • Bug 549280 - Show bookmark name in Bookmark Bar context menu
    • Bug 458427 - Data detectors for dates/times for iCal integration
    • Bug 404515 - Found items (as result of Find command) are hard to distinguish in the page (moved to Core, might be coming back)
    • Bug 386574 - Close tab too close to favicon causing drag'n'drop problems (specifically, does Stuart have any further commentary on the first part of comment 4?)

Queries

Camino 2.1b1

Camino 2.1

  • Bugs targeted at 2.1 (19) [unchanged since last meeting] has most of the 2.1 planning bugs and most essential Gecko 1.9.2-related bugs now
  • Blocking ? (25) [unchanged since last meeting]
  • Blocking + (1) [unchanged since last week]
  • Blocking - (1) [+1 since last week]

Queues